About This Food Place
If you're looking for a casual spot to grab a slice or sit down for a meal, East of Chicago Pizza on Commercial Ave is a solid choice. It's laid-back with seating that works well whether you're alone or with a group. They keep things comfortable and welcoming, making it easy to settle in for some classic comfort food. The menu sticks to straightforward, filling pizzas and sides without overcomplicating things. You can dine in, order delivery, or even enjoy the outdoors if you’re bringing a dog along. Plus, the place is easy to get around for anyone needing wheelchair access, and parking doesn't tend to be a hassle. It’s just a down-to-earth spot for grabbing some steady pizza fare.
Why People Come Here
- People come here for consistent and timely pizza takeout, with orders ready as promised.
- This place is often chosen for family-friendly buffet options that accommodate large groups, including children.
- People come here for a variety of salad and wing options that complement their pizza orders.
- This place is often selected for delivery service known for punctuality and courteous drivers, even in difficult weather conditions.
- People come here for affordable dining options within the $10–20 price range that offer fresh and consistently prepared food.
A Quick Look at the Menu
Updating...
When & How to Enjoy This Place
East of Chicago Pizza is ideal for relaxed group meals, especially when enjoying the buffet, which suits family gatherings or large parties comfortably. Solo diners will also find a welcoming spot with quick service for a satisfying solo lunch or dinner. Whether you’re grabbing a speedy takeout or settling in for a long, leisurely meal with friends, the atmosphere supports both paced dining and casual stops, making it a versatile choice for any pizza craving.
Reviews
Caiden Cronk
This place is very good, they have the best cheese sticks and very good dessert. I would come here if you like pizza and buffets.
Golden Gun (Golden Gun)
Ordered two extra large square pizzas for takeout - both done well and tasty. Ready when they said they would be! Thank you.
Lorin Kitt
Good food and the delivery guy is always really good and nice. They don't take very long at all either, always have good luck with them. The one time we gave the delivery guy a good tip because when he delivered a big storm came through and it was very nasty out. This guy was a good sport about it and we appreciated him delivering.
Shaik Abdul Raheem
Best pizza, I am going every weekend here. It’s very tasty and delicious.
tamie mcmurray
The service is amazing. And the food is delicious. We go to the buffet, which is from 12-2 and (3-5 I think) on Sundays. The food is always fresh and delicious. The restaurant is clean. And they dont even get upset when we show up after church with 20+ people, kids and all. The buffet is also not terribly expensive. There is something for all. I have a kid who doesnt like pizza and even he likes going.
Sherman Ward
Normally, we visit the berlin location when we are in town but decided to stop at this location as we were on our way home. Had 2 subs. One Italian and one chicken bacon ranch. Both were delicious, hot, and well made. Not very pricey either.
Chad Hilty
Food is good. I like the buffet but when I go and it's 30 minutes past the start time, I sit and wait 10 minutes for the first pizza. The salad bar isn't even set up yet. If you are a patient person and in no rush to eat I highly recommend the buffet. If you need to eat in 30 minutes or less, order take out. The cups are so small (free refills) I need about 10 refills per visit. I understand paper cups but this is ridiculous. Update: upon last visit they got bigger cups.
Kathy Wallar
Great food, fast delivery. Always great on the phone taking my orders. My favorite pizza place!!
When to Visit
- Monday
- Tuesday
- Wednesday
- Thursday
- Friday
- Saturday
- Sunday
- 03:00 PM - 09:00 PM
- 03:00 PM - 09:00 PM
- 03:00 PM - 09:00 PM
- 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
- 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
- 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
- 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Where This Food Place Lives
205 Commercial Ave SE, New Philadelphia, OH 44663, United States